So, it has me thinking of advice I would give teachers on how to deal with the issue of bullying. Here are a few thoughts for teachers, schools and administrators:
- Know Your Students: It's hard to find the victims. It is hard to explain the sheer terror of bullying. Your world stops. You feel edgy. It's harder, still, to explain the shame that results. You feel weak. You have this lingering cycle of, "What's wrong with me that I'm being targeted?" It's that shame that keeps bullying secretive. In my case, I wasn't afraid of speaking out because of retribution. I was afraid of speaking out, because I was afraid of being known.
- Be Vulnerable: I never told an adult, because I never knew of any adults who were bullied. The school culture is all about a one-way transparency, where students are supposed to share who they are an teachers hide behind a cloak of professionalism. We need more teachers being open with students about what it was like to be bullied.
- Ditch the Stereotypes: Bullies don't always look the way teachers assume they'll look. Sometimes they are charming, socially adept, and popular. The bullies I remember were incredibly manipulative. They were buddy-buddy with the right teachers. They knew how to game the system.
- It's Not About the Technology: Too often, schools realize they have a cyber-bullying problem and so they deal with the cyber rather than the bullying part of the issue. Bullying happens on playgrounds and in cafeterias and locker rooms.
- Avoid the Hysteria: Kids get nervous when adults look scared. They grow skeptical when the fear looks like paranoia. I'm scared of my own kids being bullied. However, if I turn it into a paranoia that's all about me, I run the risk of losing the dialogue.
- A Matter of Justice: Too often, bullying is still presented as something that is somehow preventative. If kids would just do _______ then they would be okay. That's a bit like blaming rape victims for what they were wearing. Bullying needs to be presented as a despicable crime
committedmorally weak people.(I changed that after a few comments).We need to present the action as something that it is: cruel in both action and intent. - Invest in Healing: We live in an era where schools are cutting school counselor positions. However, if schools want to take bullying seriously, they need to take counseling seriously and in a way that goes beyond, "We hired someone who will help the smart kids get to the best colleges." When I've seen students get bullied, there is often little follow-up beyond "Did it stop?" There was rarely a reminder that it gets worse and then it gets better. The pain lasts for awhile, but there's hope.
John,
ReplyDeleteYou make some very important points here, and I so appreciate your clear voice on a topic that hits so close to home for you. As I read your post, I thought about my own reactions when I hear of anything that sounds like bullying, and I realize that my "mama bear" reaction has a lot to do with my own experience as a child. Though I was not locked in a locker, I was subject to repeated verbal abuse by my peers after returning to school after long illnesses. I never told anyone either.
In any case, I think that bullying can be minimized greatly when educators consider the factors you discuss here. If we are aware and know our students well, we are more likely to see what is happening and to be there if they get brave enough to speak. We need to take the shame of being a victim and turn it into a mark courageousness when someone speaks up for themselves. Thank you again for helping us remember what is important.
Thanks, Joan. For what it's worth, being thrown into a locker wasn't as traumatic for me as the isolation, name-calling, etc. It was the repetitiveness of that type of bullying that really felt painful.
DeleteJohn, I was at the conference and Amos glad you did not leave that part out! It was a connection point for me that was so meaningful. I wondered then and later if you've considered doing speaking at schools with students and faculty specifically about bullying. If not, please consider it. I think you could make such an impact on students and teachers.
ReplyDeleteI've never really considered it. I would be honored if a school ever asked me, but that's certainly not something that I've ever pursued.
DeleteGreat list, thank you for being so honest. I was also bullied as a child and know of the deep and lasting impact that it makes. I do disagree with the way you describe bullies in #6 ("morally weak"). Children who are bullying others also need help rather than a pejorative label, which is just as unhelpful as being labeled a "victim." They need to work through the reasons they are bullying others and to be taught appropriate ways to interact, which requires our compassion and moving beyond labels and moral judgement.
ReplyDeleteAlthough I agree with your sentiment that bullies need help, I still think they deserve the descriptive label of bully and of being morally weak. I wouldn't argue that killers or rapists do not deserve labels and yet those actions are often the results of bad situations and poor socialization.
DeleteTreating the bully as another victim can be dangerous, especially when they are manipulative. True, bullies need help. However, where they are weak is morally. As long as we treat them in a way that is essentially neutral, we minimize what actually happened and we tell the victim that this was just an unfortunate event rather than a deliberate, unjust, sinister action from another person.
I'm all for compassion. I'm all for rehabilitation of bullies. However, it requires being honest about the behavior and the motives. It requires a recognition that the actions and the motives were wrong and not simply inappropriate.
Yeah, but don't you think that "morally weak" is a pretty pejorative term?
DeleteI changed the wording. After giving it some thought, I agree with anonymous and Anna. Value judgments on the people rather than the actions does little to create change.
DeleteGood post! I'm a huge fan of Michele Borba's work on empathy and I'm with her that if we can elevate their empathy, we can help children with bullying behaviors make the leap from cruelty to compassion. Hurt kids hurt kids, so I'm all for helping the perpetrators rehabilitate and heal.
ReplyDeletePlayground equipment has evolved to make things more fun for kids. Wilkins Solutions provides playground equipment in Orlando for schools, hotels, apartments and more. playgorund equipment Orlando.
ReplyDelete