Read this blog long enough and you'll hear a mantra about trust, humility, vulnerability and authenticity. I believe deeply in the idea that being vulnerable with one another draws people closer and that being humble actually leads to more authority (because people can trust a humble person).
These are the values I claim to believe. However, I found myself abandoning them during certain moments of the conference. For example, I told a fellow blogger about our globalization project, where students worked with other students in other cities to explore issues, engage with the community and express their social voice.
What I failed to mention is that there were some tough logistical issues when another school blocked Blogger. I failed to mention that some students complained about it and that as much as I tried to keep it engaging, I ultimately said, "you have to do this." I failed to mention the fact that some of the service projects weren't all that grand - a screening of a documentary and a letter-writing campaign to senators and congressional representatives.
Another time, when talking about math, I shared strategies that worked: students developing problems on their own, context-based math, multimedia prompts, blogging, etc. However, what I failed to mention is that I had a few days when I simply wasn't organized and we did bookwork.
I've told the story before about seeing the sheriff's department chasing after moms with strollers. What I often omit is that it was the custodian who had the courage to open the school gates and let families slip in for refuge.
Conferences are places where people sell things. Whether it's a vendor downstairs or a workshop presentation upstairs, there is an ethos of persuasion. Some people stay grounded better than I did. However, back here in Phoenix, I am already realizing that I spun stories. I omitted details. I exaggerated how amazing things were. I can call it anything, but the truth is that I lied. I feel horrible about it.
I did this for two reasons: first, I wanted to be well-liked. I wanted to matter. There's a dark, human desire to feel important. And if I'm feeling insecure (after I did when my ISTE proposal was rejected) it's easier for me to slip into the spin-zone mindset. My second reason is that I want to push certain ideas that are deep convictions of mine. It's more efficient to slip into propaganda than to model the very authenticity I claim to value.
When I look back at the conference, it was the moments of vulnerability that I value the most. Although I regret making the Maryvale Voice project sound important, I value the part of that conversation when I was honest about getting scared after having high test scores and then running away toward coaching. Although I regret acting like I keep up on all the blogs people write, I cherish the conversation about what it is like to blog and to open up before a community of educators.
My big take-home this year has little to do with apps or flipping or devices. Instead, my take-home has to do with me. I'm realizing again the need to be vulnerable, to be honest and to be humble. This blog used to be called "musings from a not-so master teacher," just like that free of any capital letters. Although it is now Education Rethink, I need to attend conferences remembering that I am still a not-so-master teacher.
Subscribe to our Feed Flickr
Tumblr
YouTube Channel
Twitter: @edrethink
E-mail: john@edrethink.org
Google Plus: My Profile
Instagram: My Profile
John's Site: johntspencer.com
Twitter: @edutech83
E-mail: chad@educationrethink.com
Chad's Site: chadsegersten.com

Wow.
Thanks for being honest. We all have those moments of wanting everyone to think everything is perfect. Very few ever admit what you just did.
Thank you! I respect and admire you for that.
Thank you for being honest.
I understand your thoughts. When I left Educon in Jan. I was so excited about the new ideas, but I also find myself wishing for those moment of "vulnerability" when you're working tirelessly with colleagues and students to innovate and create. Conferences showcase ideas, tools, discussions, and questions, but they don't usually offer that rich, consistent collegial time that "draws people closer." That's why PLCs and greater time for rich collaboration, innovation and design are essential in the places where we work.
In your defense, you were the guy who said that he should be wearing an "I'm kind of not a big deal" shirt.
No offense, John, but "musings" is still my favorite of all your blog titles thus far. I think it's still the most fitting.
I actually think that as teachers we don't often celebrate and toot our own horns enough when it comes to the great work we do in our classrooms everyday. I think that changes when we are surrounded by individuals with amazing stories, wonderful successes, and seem to be living a charmed life. We want to make sure that we too have something to share. I value, above everything else, a humble spirit. Humility I believe is what empowers learning. It fast tracks relationships and provides an opportunity for everyone to take centre stage.
All that being said, when we met last year @ ISTE I knew you were the real deal... and you just proved it again with your post.
Continue to reflect and share your amazing talent. It is a highly prized commodity nowadays.
ISTE rejected you? Are you kidding me? I heard you speak at Center Grove. You were amazing and inspiring! That's a huge lose for the educators that were here. You would have been my first pick.
By the way, I bet your students love you. One of the things I have learned in 16 years in a classroom is that they can spot a fake. Kids champion authenticity so keep up the good work.
Also, keep writing this blog. I enjoy your unique perspective.
I was in one of those ISTE sessions on Monday when one of presenters showed a video that a couple of her students had made. It was outstanding to say the least. What I wanted to ask her though was to show us the one that during the same assignment was not so great. Then I could feel like maybe what my students produce from my teaching isn't so bad after all.
We're all human.
John,
I think honesty and humility are two of your best qualities. That said, I don't know if they come "naturally" to anyone. I try to be honest and humble but that seems insincere to me to try to be humble. This very topic has been on my mind a lot this week as I struggle with it. This may get a bit long but I want to share a story.
Last week I was at a conference for schools new to the network that my school is a part of. I did a rehearsal for feedback of an Ignite talk that I will give at the national conference in July. I am really excited about this chance to talk in front of a large group and share something that I am passionate about. I want to use this to really make a strong statement. So on the one hand it is definitely about telling the story of my school and spreading a message against standardization. On the other hand there is definitely a part of me that wants to get my name recognized in our network of schools and beyond. That is part of the reason that I volunteered to do this is self-promotion.
So the message is more important than me, but in my heart I know that I also seek recognition for creating it and even hope to make a big splash with it that may lead to other opportunities some day. I received compliments from the dozen people in the room and could tell that I really connected with them as I had hoped. I sense that this talk is going to be powerful as I have hoped it would be.
The question is how do I stay humble and focus on the message when the truth is that the message is only half of my motivation and self-promotion is the other half? And is it wrong to want to promote myself? Is it possible to promote oneself and still be humble?
Wow, this was an intriguing post that also generated intriguing comments. Lots of human psychology here. You've said it all. Not sure I can add more other than to say, thanks for sharing and taking the time to post this.
Thanks John. I appreciate your courage to put it out there. I, for one, have done exactly what you did. And sometimes it takes me realizing that I've made mistakes in doing so, before I can be better the next time. Sounds like you are better for it already. Kudos.
First off - So great to meet you f2f. You were one of the people I got to "meet" after knowing online for a long time. Perhaps the highlight of ISTE for me was the handshakes and hugs and conversations.
Second - You called me out, on the web. And it's all good. We all do that, it doesn't make us liars or not genuine. When we want to rally teachers and help them see the benefits of whatever we are doing in our classrooms nobody points out the failures. We all know (hopefully) that *nothing* works for all your kids, and take ideas with a grain of salt. For myself, I do make a point in my workshops of pointing out some failures or challenges but it doesn't stop me from showcasing the greater good that comes from an awesome project.
Part of why I enjoyed meeting you at ISTE is knowing that you are genuine person - you are honest and call it like it is. Bumps and hairy warts and all. We all know going in that people present the best case senario, unless you intentionally left out some facts you are being hard on yourself for no good reason.
And if you still are not convinced...I really believe that sharing your ideas, even if only the highlights, can motivate teachers to try something new. Think about it - when teaching your kids do you teach them all the things that can go wrong? Or do you teach them what can be?
Isn't that always the way. I find that Pro-D is 50% inspiring, and 50% depressing. Sometimes we need to know all the steps to getting there (including pitfalls and mistakes and falterings), and we need to be validated, before we can make change.
Your honesty is enlightening. How many of us do this, not just at conferences, but in life! The thing is...You were man enough and honest enough to admit it where others do not. YOU MATTER! We all matter in the good and the bad! We do, make mistakes, learn and grow! You are now my new favorite blogger and person.
John,
This is why I enjoy collaborating with you. I think by now we each understand that neither is perfect or ever will be!
I like this Jerry McGuire moment you are having. thanks for sharing. its good to let it all out. You would not be a great teacher without such reflection and vulnerability.
Anyone who hasn't seen the Brene Brown TED talk on vulnerability should do so, now.
Hey John,
I enjoyed the authenticity of your post. Your heart is in the right place. We all make mistakes. Good on you for admitting yours. Follow that passion you have. It will never fail you. Coupled with humility and a good sense of humour - you'll go a long way.
Maurie
Sydney
After 5 years as a teacher (by no means a huge number, but enough to know a few things) I can't look at a teacher's amazing student product without 100 questions. You gave me a ton of guidance on doing a documentary film unit. After the unit was over I was incredibly glad that I did it. But, to be honest, the videos were mostly terrible. The students learned a TON of information on their topics. They also demonstrated that learning through their production process. However, technical and just plain skill level problems made the editing process painful and ineffective.
The important thing though is that my students were still learning, even if the project failed - they didn't. But, no one wants you to bring a failed project with successful learning to a conference.
Thanks for having dinner with us. It's nice to have a 4 dimensional conversation with you.
I agree! And, that IS a great TED Talk. Sometimes I wonder if the TED people should watch it :-)
I can't really add more than what's already been said except to say that honesty like this is what sets you apart from everyone else.
John - It was great to be able to spend time to talking to you at ISTE. I feel fortunate to connect with so many educators who are so open and honest about what they do and who they are. You certainly raise the bar for me in this area. I can't think of more important think for us to share than our vulnerabilities. Imagine if our students all felt safe enough to share theirs?
For me ISTE was great - But the great thing was that I am continuously reminded that I am part of a community of passionate and caring learners who want to provide the same support system back in their schools for all of their students. However, it has to start with us and nobody makes that point better than you.
Thanks John!
So, John... you are a human.... that makes me feel better about myself! Thinking of leaving instructional coaching and returning to the classroom - but I only remember the great days I had and I have been out for 10 years.... Glad to know even great teachers like you have average days!
I'm going back into the classroom after doing tech coaching as well. I know it won't be perfect. However, it will be meaningful. And ultimately that's what matters.
What struck me about you is how you have done so much and how you are so loved by your teachers and yet you are so calm, soft-spoken and humble. Here I was, having conversation with such a deep thinker, and I never felt like I was "looking up" if that makes sense. No wonder you've gained influence and still haven't sold out.
Tom, if you had been there, I have a hunch you would have called people (including me) on their b.s.
Jeff, hanging out with you, your wife and your friend was one of the highlights of the conference. You almost never advertise it, but you are doing amazing things in your classroom.
Thanks for the kind words.
I've got to check it out.
Our collaboration has been a blast, Chad. I think our authenticity toward one another is why we mesh so well.
Thanks for the reminder that it comes from a sense of identity. It starts with remembering that I matter, regardless of accomplishments.
I answered this on Twitter a little bit last night. You were one of the coolest, most approachable people I met at ISTE - no different than you are online.
I definitely crafted stories deliberately to make myself or my ideas seem more important. It wasn't a good thing. It didn't happen all the time, just several times, and I regret it.
I'm amazed at how people have responded to this post. They don't seem betrayed. They seem gracious. It's been really cool.
I think the desire is both good and bad. That's what makes it so deceptive. Part of self-promotion is a desire to belong and to matter. Part is a desire to push really good ideas. But a part is arrogance and pride.
For what it's worth, it was your humility that first drove me to your blog and it's been your humility that kept me there.
Thanks, Judy.
I'm glad you enjoyed my keynote at Center Grove. That feels encouraging.
I agree that kids can spot a fake. It's part of why I need to stay in the classroom. I can't be allowed to turn fake.
Thanks for the kind words. I agree. There are times when we need to share our wonderful stories. Sometimes in the guise of humility, we don't talk about what worked.
I feel the same way sometimes, Philip.
Ha ha! That's true. I did say that several times. I meant it, too. I am so far on the fringe of the Ed Tech crowd.
I think you're right. Co-workers and well-functioning PLCs can make a huge difference. It takes vulnerability to share data in total honesty.
Thanks, Chris.
I feel somehow . . . relieved. I almost didn't post it. I felt like the phoniest person in the world. I'm glad I did.
John - was turned on to your blog post by a friend/colleague. Great insight. I enjoyed the honesty as I will admit at times I have felt some similar things.
One insight to share - when sharing the 'positives' of a situation, project, happening, I think just that...I'm trying to share the positives. To inspire. To give hope. To show a little light on how something can work for others. There are always challenges to anything, whether they be logistical, human nature, or some other factor. If we get too caught up in the "Yeah, but this problem could happen"s, I feel like the conversation could turn negative. Many times when presenting, I get asked the "Yeah, but what about this thing that could go wrong" from someone in the crowd and through a hope to inspire the room, I focus on the positives like you shared. Is that spinning it or lying? Or is that inspiring and shooting down potential naysayers? Just posing the question (and hopefully giving you reasons to not be too hard on yourself, but again -- the honesty is appreciated and welcomed).
Great thoughts and thanks for sharing.
You became Everyman for the rest of us. Witness the wealth of meaningful replies. Thanks.
John,
As usual, your post resonates with me as I reflect on my own conversations at ISTE12 as well as the one you and I shared. I don't think that the posing and impressing happened during our reflective conversation, but I am sure that in other interactions I may have felt the need to prove myself. Talking to you was refreshing and insight provoking, and I appreciate the time we shared.
We all resort to our humanness to fill that need for belonging. And when we are honest with ourselves and each other, we clear the way for growth.
Thank you!
I think there's a difference in motive. What you describe is optimism and it has its place. For me, the real issue is that I was deliberately trying to prove myself. It was out of insecurity and pride.
Thanks. I really came close to not posting it.
For the second year in a row, I really enjoyed the conversations we had at the Blogger's Cafe. It was a blast. While you are totally authentic online, there's a bluntness that you have face-to-face that is refreshing in the midst of some of the posturing.
John,
Thank you for a thought provoking post. While at ISTE the people I could be my humble and vulnerable self with are my online friends. Those individuals that are accepting of me regardless of what has happened in either my personal or professional life. I think at times we are less truthful with those who don't know us because we all have a need to be liked and admired by others. That's part of being human.
So sorry I did not have the opportunity to meet you. Maybe next year in San Antonio.
Heh. Btw, the fact that you're taking the time to reply to all of these comments is outstanding.
I didn't get into teaching for noteriety, but for a little while it would have been hard to tell. I used to get really worked up over coworkers not embracing technology or having faulty teaching philosophies - I hit the point of hubris, thinking I had it all figured out.
It has been difficult to balance passion with temperance. But, I've found that it gets more people interested in sharing - as opposed to me talking at them. It's been a good change.
There is so much love in the comments here. Thanks for your leadership in vulnerability, John!
There is so much love in the comments here. Thanks for your leadership in vulnerability, John!
I think it is important to remember that weekend conferences are only one element in our ongoing professional, and personal development, and hopefully not a critical element at that, because I don't seem to be attending them these days. Sustained contact with people leads to honesty.
Thanks for your honesty and your reflections, especially as I am sitting in a conference right now.
John, I won't repeat the praises you've rightly garnered by your honesty, although I agree that its a great demonstration of character, but there's a "teachable moment" here that I don't think has been identified yet: the importance of failure. Being able to look at one's performance in a situation and reassess, criticize, identify and then learn from mistakes, are all skills seldom explicitly taught in school. Especially as teachers, we want to be right, to be trusted as experts, yet failing is one of the best ways to learn, and unless we model and teach making mistakes and at least reassessing if not actually redoing things, our students will lose out on one of the most important lessons we can share with them. Congratulations! You failed!