August 28, 2012

You Can't Pay Me to Be a Better Teacher

I'm exhausted tonight. It's my day without a prep and as I look back on my to-do list, I realize that I over-estimated my potential by about two hundred percent. I'll wake up around five and plug away for an hour to hour and a half tomorrow morning.

I was impatient with the kids in math. I was disappointed that their intensity couldn't match my own and I struggled to manage my small group intervention while the class wrestled with a really tough word problem.

I make a mental list of what to fix: make sure all kids are getting to the enrichment center, send home positive notes to the remaining twelve who haven't gotten them, hang up my math discourse questions on the wall, stay on top of birthdays (I've let that slide, even though they're in the calendar), get the supplies for the solar ovens, send my data to the right people, update my hours to send in for compliance . . .

I am re-reading The Hunger Games, this time thinking about my students and whether they can access the language. I'm thinking through the themes. I'm asking questions about the characters. My mind switches over prime factorization.

Next year, start with the context and the concepts and then introduce the process later. You know that works best. Let them discover the Greatest Common Factor. Let them see it matters first. 

I have no business telling people how to teach. I have no business giving keynotes. The fact that I've been given such influence still baffles me. I'm still trying to improve.

But here's the thing:

Never in the mix of all of this does money enter the equation. I'm working hard with the goal of helping students think better about life. I'm refining my practice for mixed motives (an arrogant perfectionism and a humble desire to serve). I will continue to reflect on how I'm doing regardless of pay. I will continue to look for new ideas regardless of professional development clock hours.

Whether it pans out in the end is a mystery. There are far too many human factors for me to claim that my kids will learn more or score higher or any of that. But throwing cash my way won't make me work harder, learn more or reflect better on my practice.

If you want me to thrive, just trust me and pay me a living wage. If my kids do great, be amazed that they triumphed in tough circumstances. Be honored that you get to witness their success. But don't be surprised when I feel insulted when you suggest that my value can be added and my merit can be quantified numerically.

18 comments:

  1. "an arrogant perfectionism and a humble desire to serve" -- THAT's exactly what it is, we should talk, John!:) I'm very lucky to be working with administrators who give me a lot of support and trust, I can't help but thrive and never take these for granted. I wouldn't say no to extra wages to afford a summer vacation though :) Thanks, John.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I might enjoy a little extra pay, too. However, it won't make me a better teacher.

      Delete
  2. Could it be that such incentive-based initiatives are targeting those wo don't care so much, don't work so hard, aren't as reflective, aren't so connected, don't behave so professionally, and in the end, aren't so intrinsically motivated? I'm not trying to argue for such incentives, but let's just say, if ALL teachers were as passionate on all fronts, perhaps we would not be here? Just wondering...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I see your point, but that's where the working wage comes in. How many teachers would be far more willing to teach if they were paid a decent salary to begin with? I think the baseline salary has to be high enough that folks are willing to sign up for this gig.

      Delete
  3. I could not agree more. Teachers are NOTvending machines

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Press 4B for data graph. Press 3C for direct instruction. If you would like to buy guided reading, insert another coin.

      Delete
  4. I was always tickled in Houston when I got some extra spending money during the summer based on the work of me and my students. Didn't feel cheapened. Didn't really understand the formula. I didn't do tutorials, long days, lesson plans, calls home, fundraising, spending my own money for money...and the money didn't compare to what I felt from seeing my students be successful. But it certainly didn't hurt anything ;-).

    ReplyDelete
  5. You sound like a fantastic teacher, but I bet you would have been great at anything. I'm not a teacher but I've often wondered what the world would be like if we paid teachers the kind of money that would get the best and brightest, the people like you, into the profession.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not sure "the best and the brightest" is the answer. However, the low salary does prevent a lot of great people from entering the field.

      Delete
  6. LIKE!! I read this and wanted to cry because I think there are many teachers in my school who feel this way. I work with some of the most caring and dedicated teachers around and yet we are constantly criticized for not doing enough. Thank you for your honesty and words of wisdom. I always look forward to seeing a new post from you in my inbox. Keep it coming!!!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm giving you a standing ovation RIGHT now. Especially for the "But throwing cash my way won't make me work harder, learn more or reflect better on my practice." part.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very cool! Thanks for the standing ovation!

      Delete
  8. "Where your treasure is, that's where your heart is." It hit me that my "Treasure" is my students. I love my job. I have always believed that if I ever won the lottery or if my husband ever made enough money to be considered wealthy, I would continue to teach. I look forward to going to work almost every day of the school year and I get really excited at the beginning of the year to meet my new students. I love what I do and I always feel so lucky to be working with great kids, a good solid staff, in a community that values education. I work hard and I love it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So true. Ultimately, that love is all that matters.

      Delete

Please leave a comment. I enjoy the conversation.